projects

The Rating of Russian Regions is an independent study that comprehensively assesses the effectiveness of Russian regions in the environmental, social and governance spheres on more than two hundred indicators.

Environmental rating of Russian regions

The results of the Environmental Rating - 2022 were published in Forbes magazine.

about the project

Dmitri Karyakin

The head of the Ecorating Project

The rating reflects the degree of compliance of the regional management system and its decisions with the goals of sustainable development in the fields of ecology, economy, social policy and management.
The results of the assessment can be used by public authorities of the subjects of the Russian Federation to adjust their own activities, as well as by enterprises and institutions to improve their work and use the experience of more successful regions.

In the upcoming regional ESG-assessment of 2023, Environmental protection fund - Ecophone will use data provided by people via EcoPhone App.

Move Left

6;Belgorod Oblast;0,48 BB;0,59 BBB;0,67 BBB;0,57 BBB 7;Kursk Oblast;0,56 BB;0,56 BB;0,55 BB;0,56 BB 8;Kabardino-Balkarian Republic;0,57 BBB;0,55 BB;0,54 BB;0,56 BB 9;Leningran Oblast;0,39 BB;0,49 BB;0,86 BB;0,55 BB 10;Chuvash Republic;0,49 BB;0,55 BB;0,64 BB;0,55 BB 11;Volgograd Oblast;0,54 BB;0,46 BB;0,68 BB;0,55 BB 12;Republic of Tatarstan (Tatarstan);0,52 BB;0,49 BB;0,66 BB;0,55 BB 13;Khanty-Mansi Autonomous Okrug–Yugra;0,37 BB;0,58 BB;0,76 BB;0,55 BB 14;Republic of Tuva;0,46 BB;0,55 BB;0,67 BB;0,54 BB 15;Voronezh Oblast;0,48 BB;0,58 BB;0,59 BB;0,54 BB 16;Krasnodar Krai;0,47 BB;0,52 BB;0,65 BB;0,54 BB 17;Karachay-Cherkess Republic;0,45 BB;0,54 BB;0,62 BB;0,53 BB 18;Yaroslavl Oblast;0,46 BB;0,5 BB;0,66 BB;0,52 BB 19;Krasnoyarsk Krai;0,47 BB;0,42 BB;0,75 BB;0,52 BB 20;Penza Oblast;0,44 BB;0,52 BB;0,64 BB;0,52 BB 21;Ulyanovsk Oblast;0,51 BB;0,52 BB;0,54 BB;0,52 BB 22;Bryansk Oblast;0,43 BB;0,52 BB;0,64 BB;0,52 BB 23;Lipetsk Oblast;0,46 BB;0,52 BB;0,56 BB;0,51 BB 24;Samara Oblast;0,46 BB;0,43 BB;0,7 BB;0,51 BB 25;Rostov Oblast;0,46 BB;0,46 BB;0,65 BB;0,51 BB 26;Republic of Adygea (Adygea);0,38 BB;0,52 BB;0,66 BB;0,51 BB 27;Stavropol Krai;0,34 BB;0,61 BB;0,6 BB;0,51 BB 28;Chechen Republic;0,42 BB;0,56 BB;0,53 BB;0,5 BB 29;Tambov Oblast;0,53 BB;0,51 BB;0,46 BB;0,5 BB 30;Kaluga Oblast;0,43 BB;0,41 BB;0,72 BB;0,5 BB 31;Republic of Bashkortostan;0,51 BB;0,44 BB;0,54 BB;0,49 BB 32;Kamchatka Krai;0,5 BB;0,37 BB;0,63 BB;0,49 BB 33;Novosibirsk Oblast;0,40 BB;0,47 BB;0,64 BB;0,49 BB 34;Republic of Kalmykia;0,56 BB;0,54 BB;0,3 BB;0,48 BB 35;Republic of Sakha (Yakutia);0,40 BB;0,47 BB;0,62 BB;0,48 BB 36;Republic of Altai;0,49 BB;0,49 BB;0,46 BB;0,48 BB 37;Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug;0,41 BB;0,44 BB;0,63 BB;0,48 BB 38;Republic of North Ossetia-Alania;0,46 BB;0,58 BB;0,35 BB;0,48 BB 39;Sakhalin Oblast;0,36 BB;0,42 BB;0,7 BB;0,47 BB 40;Republic of Mari El;0,38 BB;0,47 BB;0,59 BB;0,47 BB 41;Sverdlovsk Province;0,35 B;0,47 BB;0,59 BBB;0,47 BB 42;Nizhni Novgorod Province;0,37 B;0,47 BB;0,58 BBB;0,47 BB 43;Tver Oblast;0,45 BB;0,42 B;0,53 BB;0,46 BB 44;Saratov Oblast;0,37 B;0,40 B;0,67 BBB;0,46 BB 45;Ryazan Oblast;0,42 B;0,34 B;0,66 BBB;0,46 BB 46;Murmansk Oblast;0,39 B;0,45 BB;0,57 BBB;0,46 BB 47;Arkhangelsk Oblast;0,44 B;0,42 B;0,53 BB;0,46 BB 48;Tula Oblast;0,37 B;0,48 B;0,56 BB;0,46 BB 49;Orenburg Oblast;0,44 B;0,41 B;0,54 BB;0,46 BB 50;Republic of Mordovia;0,35 B;0,56 BBB;0,45 BB;0,45 BB 51;Orel Oblast;0,48 BB;0,49 BB;0,35 B;0,45 BB 52;Omsk Oblast;0,35 B;0,42 B;0,64 BBB;0,45 BB 53;Privorski Krai;0,43 B;0,34 B;0,63 BBB;0,45 BB 54;Republic of Ingushetia;0,45 BB;0,52 BB;0,33 B;0,45 BB 55;Sevastopol City;0,32 CCC;0,44 B;0,63 BBB;0,45 BB 56;Kemerovo Oblast;0,44 BB;0,37 B;0,52 BB;0,44 B 57;Republic of Udmurtia;0,42 B;0,54 BB;0,31 CCC;0,44 B 58;Astrakhan Oblast;0,39 B;0,41 B;0,51 BB;0,43 B 59;Republic of Dagestan;0,44 BB;0,47 BB;0,33 B;0,43 B 60;Vladimir Oblast;0,32 CCC;0,35 B;0,69 A;0,42 B 61;Republic of Buryatia;0,31 CCC;0,46 BB;0,53 BB;0,42 B 62;Novgorod Oblast;0,37 B;0,35 B;0,62 BBB;0,42 B 63;Republic of Karelia;0,34 B;0,47 BB;0,47 BB;0,42 B 64;Ivanovo Province;0,3 CCC;0,47 BB;0,52 BB;0,42 B 65;Chukotka Autonomous Okrug;0,52 BB;0,45 BB;0,23 CCC;0,42 B 66;Nenets Autonomous Okrug;0,37 B;0,44 B;0,44 BB;0,42 B 67; Komi Republic;0,29 CCC;0,45 BB;0,52 BB;0,41 B 68;Khabarovsk Krai;0,35 B;0,49 BB;0,37 B;0,41 B 69;Tomsk Oblast;0,40 B;0,51 BB;0,27 CCC;0,41 B 70;Perm Krai;0,39 B;0,43 B;0,40 B;0,41 B 71;Kaliningrad Oblast;0,38 B;0,37 B;0,49 BB;0,41 B 72;Amur Oblast;0,40 B;0,29 CCC;0,55 BB;0,40 B 73;Smolensk Oblast;0,40 B;0,38 B;0,43 B;0,40 B 74;Republic of Crimea;0,33 B;0,34 B;0,57 BBB;0,39 B 75;Kostroma Oblast;0,43 B;0,36 B;0,39 B;0,39 B 76;Kirov Oblast;0,39 B;0,36 B;0,44 B;0,39 B 77;Chelyabinsk Oblast;0,3 CCC;0,41 B;0,49 BB;0,39 B 78;Zabaykalsky Krai;0,25 CCC;0,44 B;0,51 BB;0,39 B 79;Pskov Oblast;0,45 BB;0,40 B;0,25 CCC;0,38 B 80;Magadan Province;0,47 BB;0,38 B;0,25 CCC;0,38 B 81;Irkutsk Oblast;0,38 B;0,33 B;0,43 B;0,36 B 82;Altai Krai;0,24 CCC;0,43 B;0,44 B;0,36 B 83;Republic of Khakassia;0,38 B;0,39 B;0,29 CCC;0,36 B 84;Jewish Autonomous Oblast;0,36 B;0,44 BB;0,21 CC;0,35 B 85;Kurgan Oblast;0,36 B;0,34 B;0,33 B;0,34 B

download rating (rus)

Goals

Data

Rating indicators are calculated on the basis of information from ministries, departmental organizations and interdepartmental information systems

features

taking into account modern trends of green agenda

Оценка субъектов в целом

Показателей оценки

Экологический, социальный и управленческий аспекты

Учет государственных программы и федеральных проектов

Учет многолетней динамики

Учет данных активистов со всей страны с помощью Экофона

климатические риски

карбоновые полигоны

«зеленые инвестиции»

углеродную нейтральность

200+

Rating indicators

ESG-aspects

Assess for state programs and federal projects

years

Review for long-term dynamics

Consideration data sent by eco-activists from all over the country via EcoPhone

Overall assessment of regions

climate risks

green investments

carbon polygons

Carbon neutrality

Starting from 2023, Environmental protection fund - Ecophone will use data provided by people via EcoPhone App in its ESG-assessment of Russian regions.

Methodology

The final rating score for each region consists of the sum of indicator scores distributed over three blocks. Each of the blocks has a specific weight in the overall rating

37%

environmental pillar

indicators show the environmental situation

volume of waste

water quality

climate

presence of protected areas

soil quality

energy development

weight of the block

air quality

social pillar

indicators show socio-economic development of the region

demography

science and education

housing and infrastructure

income and expenditures

employment

medicine

weight of the block

33%

governance pillar

indicators show the effectivness of state management in the region and financial data

weight of the block

30%

managment effectiveness

financial indicators

download (rus)

Depending on the results, each region receives a value on a scale from 0 to 1.
The better the situation, the closer the score is to 1, and vice versa. These ranges are assigned a letter grade: from C ("insufficient compliance with environmental, social, and governance standards") to the highest level of AAA.

С 11110,00-0,1
CC 110,11-0,22
ССС 0,22-0,33

В1111 0,33-0,44
ВВ11 0,44-0,56
ВВВ 0,56-0,67

А111110,67-0,78
АА1110,78-0,89
ААА 0,89-1,00

Environmental Pillar

Social Pillar

Governance Pillar

documents

Methodology for assigning ESG ratings to the regions of the Russian Federation

Environmental Rating Table 2022

Expert assessment of Methodology for assigning ESG-ratings

Environmental Rating 2022 was published in November issue of Forbes magazine

partners